| Name | Year |
|---|---|
| William C. Beener Jr. | 1965 |
| Albertus VanderMeer | 1968 |
| Michael Derrick | 1970 |
| Thomas O'Brien | 1970 |
| John J. Reso | 1970 |
| Joseph Harvey | 1971 |
| Donald Hand | 1975 |
| Raymond Sands | 1976 |
| Jack Nolan | 1979 |
| Anthony Kostreba Jr. | 1985 |
| Charles Bergen | 1991 |
| John Kennedy Jr. | 1997 |
| Vincent D'Aversa | 1998 |
| James Felkey | 1998 |
| William Whitecraft | 1998 |
| C. William Winslade | 1998 |
| Elmont Cheesman | 1998 |
| Gary Margerum | 1998 |
| Edward Rupprecht | 1999 |
| Russell Bellmont | 1999 |
| Gene Cadwallader | 1999 |
| John Cadwallader Jr. | 2000 |
| James Coyne | 2000 |
| Daniel Felver | 2000 |
| Robert J. Hairhoger | 2000 |
| Richard Worrell | 2000 |
| Michael Margerum | 2001 |
| Walter Shimp | 2001 |
| Kevin Bunn | 2002 |
| Norman Hunsinger | 2002 |
| Dennis Kennedy | 2002 |
| George Mershon III | 2002 |
| James Sheridan | 2002 |
| Gary Wertz | 2002 |
| Richard Cole | 2003 |
| Robert Hibbs | 2003 |
| John Hoffman | 2004 |
| Henry Hoffmeister | 2004 |
| John Dye | 2006 |
| Ronald LaRue | 2006 |
| Bruce Pellegrino | 2006 |
| Kenneth Kotnarowski | 2007 |
| David Neeld | 2007 |
| Chris Bunn | 2008 |
| Paul Fort | 2008 |
| Richard Habgood | 2008 |
| Alan McClister | 2008 |
| John Poiron | 2008 |
| Daniel Sweeney | 2009 |
| Patrick Kobol | 2012 |
| Robert J. Meier | 2012 |
| Glenn Chamberlain | 2013 |
| Felix Devaney | 2016 |
| Joseph Devaney | 2016 |
| James Foulds II | 2016 |
| Rowland C. Girton Sr. | 2016 |
| Stephen Melchiore | 2016 |
| Tim K. Heasley | 2017 |
| Wilford Ken Richards | 2018 |
| Greg Kobol | 2019 |
| John Kingham | 2020 |
| Mike Plassa | 2020 |
| Wes Foraker | 2021 |
| Ron Workman | 2021 |
